Peer Review Feedback Template

Research Prompts Claude 3.5 Sonnet 7 views 0 copies

Write structured, constructive peer review feedback with major/minor concerns and recommendation.

Prompt

Provide constructive peer review feedback for this [Paper Type: journal article / conference paper / thesis chapter] in [Field]:

[Paste the paper or abstract/key sections]

Structured review:
1. Overall assessment (1 paragraph)
2. Summary of contribution (what it claims to do)
3. Major concerns (2-3 fundamental issues):
   - Methodology soundness
   - Argument logic
   - Evidence quality
   - Contribution to field
4. Minor concerns (formatting, citations, clarity)
5. Specific line-by-line suggestions (for key sections)
6. Questions for the author
7. Recommendation: Accept / Minor revisions / Major revisions / Reject
8. Rationale for recommendation

Tone: Professional, constructive, specific. Critique the work not the author. Suggest solutions not just problems.

How To Use This Prompt

Paste the paper or key sections. Specify the field for appropriate domain-specific feedback.

Example Output

          Overall Assessment: This paper addresses a meaningful gap in the organizational psychology literature. The mixed-methods design is creative, but the quantitative component has significant sampling concerns that undermine...        

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the "Peer Review Feedback Template" prompt used for?

Write structured, constructive peer review feedback with major/minor concerns and recommendation.

Which AI models work with this prompt?

This prompt works best with Claude 3.5 Sonnet. You can also try it with other large language models for similar results.

Can I modify this prompt?

Yes! Feel free to copy and customize this prompt to better fit your specific needs. You can change names, industries, tones, or any other variables to personalize the output.

Is this prompt free to use?

Absolutely. All prompts on GetPromptPro are free to copy and use for personal or commercial purposes.